Phosphorous status and adsorption characteristics of acid soils from Cheha and Dinsho districts, southern highlands of Ethiopia

Abstract

Background

Though soils in the study areas are characterized by higher iron and aluminum oxides, and low available P contents, study on P adsorption characteristics is limited. The purpose of this experiment was to evaluate adsorption properties of selected soils and determine the standard phosphorous requirements of the soils. In this experiment, separately weighed 2 g soil samples were equilibrated in 50 ml of 0.01 M CaCl₂ solution containing KH₂PO₄ at rates of 0, 1, 2.0, 4.0, 8.0, 16.0, 24.0, and 32.0 mg P L⁻¹.

Results

The Freundlich model was found to be the best model for the description of the P adsorption characteristics of the soils. The Freundlich coefficient K_f ranged from 123.32 to 315.31 mg P kg⁻¹. The Goha-1 soil had the highest K_f (315.31 mg P kg⁻¹) as Ketasire had lowest K_f (123.32 mg P kg⁻¹) values. The value of SPR_f was ranged from 50.50 to 154.02 mg P kg⁻¹ for soils of the study area. Highly significant (P ≤ 0.01) correlation was observed between the Freundlich adsorption parameters and soil physicochemical properties.

Conclusion

The standard P requirement of the studied soils was higher than the blanket P fertilizer rate recommendations in Ethiopia. Lack of inadequate knowledge about internal and external P requirement of each crop might have decreased yield in the study areas as it could have resulted in under-application of fertilizer P. The presence of high correlation between the adsorption parameters and the soil properties suggested the indices’ prominent role in explaining P adsorption characteristics of the soils. Since higher dose of P is required by soils in the study area because of fixation, alternative P management strategies is needed to reduce P adsorption and enhance P availability.

Background

Phosphorus (P) in soils is important because adequate availability of this nutrient among other nutrients is required for plant growth and crop production. However, in acidic soils, leaching of elements such as Ca, Mg, K and Na, silicates and carbonates, and transformations of Fe and Al into oxides or oxyhydroxides creates new functional groups for P adsorption (Jesse et al. 2016). Phosphorus (P) deficiency is particularly widespread in rain-fed upland farming systems throughout the tropics and remains a major plant nutrient constraint (Asmare et al. 2015). Similar to the other agricultural soils of the tropics Ethiopian soils are generally low in P (Mamo and Haque 1987) and hence P is one of the limiting elements in crop production in the highlands of the country. Therefore, P application has become an essential part of crop production systems in order to provide adequate food and fiber for human consumption (Jalali 2007).

Phosphorous reacts readily with metallic species and in highly weathered acidic soils, Fe and Al oxyhydroxides are the dominant species with which adsorption of P occurs principally via the formation of an inner-sphere complex between orthophosphate anions and amorphous oxides [Fe_ox and Al_ox (Tan 2000; Sims and Pierzynski 2005; Ahmed et al. 2008; Rayment and Lyons 2011)]. These short range crystalline oxyhydroxides (amorphous) are well known to affect P sorption in soils (Janardhanan and Daroup 2010). Phosphorus adsorption depends on the nature and quality of sites available on the mineral surfaces and is therefore affected by high clay contents (Bahia et al. 1983). Studies also revealed that (Bedin et al. 2003; Moreira et al. 2006) the presence of large proportions of sesquioxides on clays, pH, exchangeable aluminum and organic matter influence phosphate adsorption and precipitation with iron and aluminum.

The extent of P adsorption and availability greatly varies from soil to soil owing to their differences in physicochemical properties (Muindi et al. 2015) and management (Moazed et al. 2010). Thus, understanding the P-sorption characteristics of soils are important for designing appropriate management strategies and predicting fertilizer requirements that are needed to be applied (Zhang et al. 2005). Most of the current management strategies rely on measuring P availability by leaching the soil with an extractant (Hansen and Strawn 2003). However, sorption reactions and phosphorous buffer capacity (PBC) of soils play an important role in both agronomic and environmental P management aspects. Sorption isotherms are much used to characterize the retention of P and the PBC of soil (Yli-halla et al. 2002).

Phosphorus availability to plants is mainly ruled by three factors: (i) the concentration of P in the soil solution (‘intensity’ factor, I), (ii) the amount of P in the solid phase that can be easily made available to plants (‘quantity’ factor, Q), and (iii) the capacity of soil to keep the P concentration in soil solution sufficiently high (P buffer capacity, PBC) (Sánchez-Alcalá et al. 2014). The capacity of the soil to adsorb P greatly influences plant responses to applied P fertilizers and the calibration of soil tests for P (Amrani et al. 1999). Therefore, knowledge of the ability of the soil to adsorb P fertilizer is required to provide an accurate estimate on the P fertilizer requirements of soils (Jalali 2007). This could be obtained by determining the amount of P adsorbed by soils at a concentration of phosphorus in solution known to be non-limiting to plant growth (Henry and Smith 2003).

Although most highland soils are characterized by soil acidity and high P fixation capacity due to intensive weathering and leaching attributed to high rainfall conditions (Desta 2015), little is known about soil P adsorption capacity and P fertilizer requirements of soils in Ethiopian highlands. Moreover, factors affecting the adsorption capacity of the soils and appropriate amount of P fertilizer required by the soils of the study area have not yet been investigated. Thus, the objective of the present work was to evaluate the P adsorption characteristics of soils and estimate the adequate amount of fertilizer P required by the soils and relate the coefficients of the adsorption models to the soil chemical properties.

Methods

Description of the study area

The study was conducted in Ethiopian highlands of Dinsho district in Bale zone and Cheha district in Gurage zone, Ethiopia (Fig. 1). Dinsho district lies between 6°58′40″ and 7°20′0″ N, and 39°44′0″ and 40°26′40″ E. Physiographically, most of the land area of the district is situated above 2000 m above sea level (masl). The district is classified into three agro-climatic zones: highlands (2300–2600 masl), midlands (1500–2300), and lowlands (1200–1500). The district has a bimodal rainfall distribution with mean annual rainfall of about 1150 mm. The maximum and minimum mean annual temperatures of the District are 17.5 and 6 °C, respectively. Wheat and barley are some of the major cereal crops grown in the area. The major reference soil groups in the district are Pellic Vertisols, Eutric Cambisols, Eutric Nitosols (now Nitisols), and Chromic Luvisols (FAO 1984).

Fig. 1

Location Map of the Study Areas, a Oromia and SNNP regions in Ethiopia, b Cheha district in SNNP region, c Dinsho district in Oromia region, d Cheha district, e Dinsho district

Cheha district is situated between 8°32′0″ and 8°20′0″ N, and 37°41′20″ and 38°2′40″ E, at an elevation that ranges from 900 to 2812 masl. EIAR (2011) classified the area into three agro-ecological zones i.e. highlands (2300–3200 masl), midlands (1500–2300 masl), and lowlands (500–1500 masl) based on the bimodal rain fall system. The 10 years mean annual rainfall of the district is about 1268 mm. The mean annual maximum and minimum temperatures are 24.97 and 10.69 °C, respectively. The dominant soil types are Eutric Nitosols, Leptosols, and Pellic Vertisols (FAO 1984).

Site selection, soil sampling, and soil analysis

A preliminary soil survey and field observation was made using topographic map (1:50,000) of the study area. Soil pH (potentiometer), altitude (GPS), and slope (clinometer) were used as criteria for selection of soil sampling sites. Fifteen (15) sub-samples were collected from each sampling site to make one composite sample. Accordingly, twelve composite soil samples (0–15 cm), seven from Cheha district (Goha 1, Goha 2, Goha 3, Aftir, Abret, Kechot, and Moche), and five from Dinsho district (Doyomarufa 1, Doyomarufa 2, Tulu, Weni, and Ketasire) having pH values of less than 5.5 were obtained within an altitudinal range of 2000–3000 masl and slope less than 8% (Table 1). Soil pH was measured at field condition using portable pH meter to select soils having a pH of less than 5.5. The soil samples were put in plastic bag, tagged, and transported to laboratory for analysis during the 2014/15. Consequently, adequate (about 1 kg) amount of composited soil samples were air dried and ground to pass through a 2 mm sieve for analysis of selected soil chemical and physical properties except organic carbon and total nitrogen in which case the samples were passed through a 0.5 mm sieve.

Table 1 Sampling locations and site description

Analysis of soil physical and chemical properties

Soil particle size distribution was analyzed by the Bouyoucus hydrometer method (Day 1965). Soil bulk density was measured from three undisturbed soil samples collected using a core sampler following the procedure described by Jamison et al. (1950). Soil pH measured potentiometrically in H₂O and 1 M KCl solution at the ratio of 1:2.5 for soil: water and soil:KCl solutions using a combined glass electrode pH meter (Van Reeuwijk 1992). Cation exchange capacity (CEC) of the soils was determined by making use of the method suggested by Lavkulich (1981). Exchangeable acidity was determined by saturating the soil samples with 1 M KCl solution and titrating with 0.02 M NaOH as described by Rowell (1994). Soil organic carbon was determined by the dichromate oxidation method as described by Walkley and Black (1934). Available P was determined as Mehlich-3 P by shaking the soil samples with an extracting solution of 0.2 M CH₃COOH + 0.25 M NH₄NO₃ + 0.015 M NH₄F + 0.013 M HNO₃ + 0.001 M EDTA for 5 min (Mehlich 1984) and total soil P was determined using the method stated by Olsen and Sommers (1982).

The P fractions were successively extracted with 1 M NH₄Cl (available Pi), 0.5 NaHCO₃ (labile P_i and Po adsorbed on the soil surface), 0.1 M NaOH (moderately labile Pi and Po held more strongly by chemisorption to surfaces of Al and Fe oxides), Sonicate + 0.1 M NaOH (Pi and Po adsorbed within surfaces of Al and Fe oxides of soil aggregates-occluded P), 1 M HCl (P associated to Ca, derived from primary mineral-apatite) and a mixture of HNO₃ and HClO₄ (residual P-non-labile, stable Po forms and relatively insoluble Pi forms) as described by Hedley et al. (1982) and modified by Chen et al. (2000). The oxalate extractable P, Al and Fe (P_ox, Al_ox and Fe_ox) were determined with 0.05 M ammonium oxalate ((NH₄)₂C₂O₄.2H₂O, pH 3.3) for 2 h in the dark (Mckeague and Day 1966). Citrate bicarbonate dithionite-extractable Fe and Al (Fe_d and Al_d) were determined by the method of Mehra and Jackson (1960). The degree of P saturation (DPS) was determined as the percentage of the ratio of the different forms of P to the oxalate extractable Al and Fe (Al_ox and Fe_ox) as follows (Van der Zee et al. 1988).

Phosphorous adsorption characteristic study

In view of the results of several studies on adsorption characteristics of acidic soils of Ethiopia (Birru et al. 2003; Asmare 2014; Zinabu et al. 2015) and P adsorption kinetics of the studied soils (Bereket 2017) (unpublished) it was decided to use low initial P concentrations for adsorption experiments. Data for plotting P adsorption isotherms were obtained by equilibrating triplicate samples of 2 g of each soil. Following the procedure of Fox and Kamprath (1970), separate air-dried ground soil was equilibrated in 50 ml of 0.01 M CaCl₂ supporting electrolytes containing KH₂PO₄ at rates of 0.0, 1.0, 2.0, 4.0, 8.0, 16.0, 24.0, and 32.0 mg P L⁻¹. Three drops of toluene were added to each container to inhibit microbial activity. Three similar sets of containers for each soil were prepared and equilibration was carried out in 50 ml tube for 24 h at 25 °C. Each tube was covered with stopper to check the water losses through evaporation. Immediately after equilibration, the tubes were centrifuged and the supernatant solution was filtered through Wattman 42 filter paper and P content of the supernatant was determined using the ascorbic acid molybdenum blue color method (Watanabe and Olsen 1965). The quantities of P adsorbed by the soil were calculated from the difference between the initially applied P and the equilibrium soil solution P concentration (Yli-Halla et al. 2002). The P adsorption properties of the soil samples were studied with the Q/Ce (Q = adsorbed P and Ce = equilibrium P concentration) plot technique. Meanwhile, soil external P requirements were determined by substituting the desired P concentration into the fitted equations (Dodor and Oya 2000). The adsorption data were fitted to the Langmuir and Freundlich models and coefficients of the equations which best describe the sorption data has been used for a correlation study. The linear form of the Langmuir model could be written as:

$$ 1/{\text{Q}} = 1/{\text{Q}}_{{{\text{max}}}} + 1/({\text{KL}} \, {\text{Q}}_{{{\text{max}}}}\, \text{Ce}) $$

where Q = amount of P adsorbed (mg P Kg⁻¹), Q_max = maximum amount of P adsorbed (mg P Kg⁻¹ soil), Ce = equilibrium P concentration (mg P L⁻¹), K_L = affinity coefficient between phosphate ions and the surface of soil particles, which is related to the bonding energy (L mg ⁻¹).

The linear form of the Freundlich model can be written as:

$$ {\text{logQ}} = {\text{logKf}} + {\text{N logCe}} $$

where Q = amount of P adsorbed (mg P kg⁻¹), Ce = equilibrium solution P concentration (mg P L⁻¹) and K_f and N are fitting parameters (buffer power). The K_f values represents the amount of P adsorbed (mg kg⁻¹) at unit equilibrium concentration.

From the adsorption isotherms, the standard P requirement (SPR) (mg kg⁻¹) of the soil was determined. The SPR is the amount of P required to maintain an equilibrium concentration of 0.2 mg P L⁻¹ in soil solution which has been shown to be a threshold for many crops. The PBC was derived by the first derivative of Q to Ce, from the non-linear Q-Ce curve (Ehlert et al. 2003) i.e. the slope of the curve at 0.2 mg P L⁻¹ concentration of P (Morel et al. 2000).

The dQ/dCe of the Freundlich model is computed as:

$$ {\text{dq/dCe}} = \text{{K}}_{\text{f}} \times \;{\text{N}} \times {\text{Ce}}^{{\text{N} - 1}} $$

Similarly, the dQ/dCe of the Langmuir model is as follows:

$$ {\text{dq/dC}} = {\text{Q}_{\text{max}}} \times {\text{K}}_{\text{L}} / ( 1 {\text{ + C}}_{\text{e}} \times {\text{K}}_{\text{L}} )^{ 2} $$

Statistical analysis

The experimental data were statistically analyzed using SAS version 9.00 (SAS 2004). The fit of each adsorption model was evaluated by the determination coefficient (R²) and root mean square error (RMSE) at a confidence level of 95%. Furthermore, the coefficients of the Freundlich model were correlated with the chemical properties of the studied soils.

Results and discussion

Physicochemical properties of the studied soils

The textural class of studied soils was predominantly clayey. In this regard, the clay content of the studied soils ranged from 36.6 to 49.8% and the highest clay content was recorded from SC3 soil, while the lowest was obtained from SD3 soil. The variation in percent clay among the soils studied could be attributed to land use history, the intensity of cultivation. On this subject Onweremadu et al. (2007) noted slight temporal textural differences in arable soils resulting from continuous cultivation. The pH (H₂O) value of the soils varied between 4.65 and 5.45. Based on the rating suggested by Jones (2003), very strongly acidic soils accounted for 58%, while 42% of the studied soils could be categorized as strongly acidic suggesting the presence of substantial quantities of exchangeable hydrogen and aluminum ions which are associated with acidity (Table 2).

Table 2 Selected physicochemical properties of the soils

The cation exchange capacity of the studied soils ranged from 21.15 to 36.03 cmol_c kg⁻¹. According to Hazelton and Murphy (2007) the CEC of the soils were in the range of moderate to high values. The variation in CEC among the soils might be due to the differences in OM content, clay mineral content and pH range of the soils (Table 2). In agreement with the current study Peinemann et al. (2002) reported that clay and organic matter are the main sources of CEC and the more clay and organic matter (humus) a soil contains, the higher its CEC. The exchangeable acidity and exchangeable Al of the studied soils were found to be in the range of 0.56–2.61 cmolc kg⁻¹ and 0.21–1.54 cmolc kg⁻¹, respectively. The variability in exchangeable Al in soils was probably due to the different soil types and other soil chemical properties, such as pH, the organic matter content and CEC of the soils (Al Baquy et al. 2017).

The percentage of organic carbon in soils in the study area was ranged from 1.58 to 2.58% (Table 2). In general, as per the rating developed by Hazelton and Murphy (2007) OC content of soils of the study area were ranged from moderate with average structural condition and stability (1.00–1.80%) to high (1.80–3.00%) with a good structural condition and stability. The variation in percent organic carbon in soils of the study area could be attributed to the management practices. Many studies confirm that carbon retention in soil is influenced by crop management systems, such as crop rotation (Saljnikov-Karbozova et al. 2004), tillage (Saljnikov et al. 2009), residue management (Rasmussen et al. 1980) and fertilization and fertility (Saljnikov et al. 2005).

The amount of P extracted with Mehlich-3 ranged from 8.90 to 25.75 mg kg⁻¹. However, there was a considerable variation among soils of the districts in terms of the available P. As per the rating established by EthioSIS (2014), Mehlich-3 extractable P contents of studied soils could be qualified as very low (0–15 mg kg⁻¹) and low (15–30 mg kg⁻¹) for soils. Soils of the study area were appeared to have different concentrations of dithionite-citrate-bicarbonate (DCB) and oxalate extractable Fe, Al, and P. Consequently, Al_ox contents of the soils varied between 78.148 and 147.37 mmol kg⁻¹; Fe_ox, 73.75 and 174.69 mmol kg⁻¹; Pox, 5.51 and 12.29 mmol kg⁻¹; DPS, 4.13 and 18.62%. In view of the cut off point for loss of P due to runoff (Ige et al. 2005) all the studied soils, showed DPS values less than 20% indicating no risk of P loss from soil. These low values might be attributed to the higher adsorption capacity of these soils for applied P fertilizer.

The relative abundances of P forms in the studied soils were in the following order: Res-P > NaOH-Po > NaOH-Pi > HCl-P > (NaOH-Pi)sn > (NaOH-Po)sn > NaHCO₃-Po > NaHCO₃-Pi > NH₄Cl-P in soils from Cheha District and HCl-P > Res-P > NaOH-Po > NaOH-Pi > (NaOH-Po)sn > (NaOH-Pi)sn > NaHCO₃-Po > NaHCO₃-Pi > NH₄Cl-P for soils of Dinsho district. The labile P (Pi in NH₄Cl + Pi and Po in NaHCO₃) varied between 1.09 and 2.15% suggesting plant growth could be affected due to the presence of low biologically available P forms (Kiflu et al. 2017). The moderately labile P (Pi + Po in NaOH) called the Fe–Al associated P was varied between 22.88 and 48.77% and appeared to be very high compared to other fractions. The relatively higher abundance of Al and Fe bound P could be as a result of the presence of variable Al and Fe contents in soils at various stages of relative development and their reaction with soil P (Kiflu et al. 2017). On the other hand the P associated to Ca (HCl-Pi) varied between 11.00 and 35.75% which could be attributed to the difference in Ca contents of the studied soils and the residual-P varied between 26.78 and 30.34% (Table 2).

Phosphorous adsorption characteristics

Phosphorous adsorption isotherms

The preliminary investigation we carried out on phosphorous adsorption kinetics exhibited a period of 24 h for maximum P adsorption. Furthermore, the kinetic models also pointed out that the best linear regression was observed at lower initial P concentrations. Therefore, Phosphate adsorption isotherms of the studied soils were determined by plotting the equilibrium concentration of phosphate (Ce) against the amount of phosphate adsorbed (Q) which was resulted from 24 h equilibration period.

A graphical illustration of the adsorption isotherms of the studied soils with different curves followed a smooth plateau pattern depicting variation in data set, where shape of isotherms appeared to vary with soil characteristics was presented in Figs. 2, 3 and 4. It can be seen that the phosphorous adsorption and equilibrium P concentrations were found to increase with increasing levels of added P (0.5–32 mg P L⁻¹) in all the soils under investigation. In this regard Barrow (2015) reported that the amount of phosphate adsorbed by soil increases with increases in the solution concentration of phosphate. However, a sharp increase in phosphorous sorption was showed at lower concentrations and eventually approached a stable state at higher concentrations. This might be attributed to the unavailability of more adsorption sites for P to be adsorbed as P is further added to the soil. In concurrent with the present study Bai et al. (2012) also found that the P adsorption on the three soils consistently showed a sharp increase at lower initial P levels, and then approached a steady state at higher phosphorus levels. The slopes of the sorption curves showed that the amount of P adsorbed by the soils differed among the studied soils. Therefore, it is evident from these isotherms (Figs. 2, 3 and 4) that soils in the study area exhibited different adsorption characteristics. The probable reason for this variation in adsorption capacity may be the disparity among the soils in terms of soil properties which control the availability of P such as pH, clay content, organic matter, and oxides of Al or Fe (Bedin et al. 2003; Moreira et al. 2006).

Fig. 2

Adsorption Isotherms of SC1, SD1, SC2 and SC6 soils

Fig. 3

Adsorption Isotherms of SC4, SD4, SD5 and SC5 soils

Fig. 4

Adsorption Isotherms of SD2, SC7, SC3 and SD3 soils

Phosphorous adsorption indices

Fitting adsorption data to the adsorption equations was carried out by plotting the data in the linearized forms of the adsorption equations. The goodness of fit was evaluated by simple linear regression coefficients calculated for the linear transforms (Figs. 5, 6, 7). Plotting the adsorption data of the studied soils in the linear form of the Langmuir and Freundlich equations resulted in comparable and highly significant relationships between P in equilibrium solution and P adsorbed by soil.

Fig. 5

Freundlich adsorption curves and equations for SC1, SC6, SD2 and SD5 soils

Fig. 6

Freundlich adsorption curves and equations for SC2, SC3, SD1, and SD3 soils

Fig. 7

Freundlich adsorption curves and equations for SC4, SC5, SD7, and SD4 soils

The adsorption indices (coefficients) of linearized form of both models are presented in Table 3. Accordingly, the adsorption maxima (Q_max) of the soils were ranged from 680.22 to 1112.11 mg kg⁻¹ at 24 h equilibration period (Table 3), indicating different concentration of the strong sites (Fe_ox and Al_ox) might have influenced the adsorption capacity of the soils (Chunye et al. 2009). The lowest (680.22 mg P kg⁻¹) and the highest (1112.11 mg P kg⁻¹) Q_max values were observed in SD1 and SC1 soils from the adsorption study respectively. The variations in Q_max might be associated with the amount of Fe_ox and Al_ox present in the soils. In agreement with the present study, Campos et al. (2016) examined tropical soils with Q_max ranging from 60 to 5500 mg kg⁻¹, and found that Al and Fe were critical ions in controlling P sorption in these soils. Moreover, very inconsistent Q_max values have been reported by several studies from different parts of the country, of which Birru et al. (2003) selected 16 soil samples from Northwestern Highlands of Ethiopia and reported very low value (5–108 mg P kg⁻¹) compared to the current study. On the other hand, soils under the present study appeared to have lower Q_max as compared to acidic soils in Wonago district, southern Ethiopia (Zinabu 2015). Likewise, the PBC_L determined at the standard P concentration in the 24 h of equilibration period ranged from 85 to 398 L kg⁻¹ and was within the range found by Asmare (2014) and Zinabu et al. (2015) in different acidic soils of the country.

Table 3 The Freundlich and Langmuir model parameters, SPR, PBC, MBC, RMSE and r² values after 24 h equilibration period

The result of the regression analysis of the data from the Langmuir model showed that the adsorption energy coefficient or binding energy constant of P on the adsorption sites (K_L) values ranged from 0.09 to 1.13 L mg⁻¹ at 24 h equilibration period indicating the studied soils had variable adsorption energy coefficient. Lin and Banin (2005) reported 0.25–0.26 and 0.02–0.05 L mg⁻¹ of the binding energy constants on the strong sites and weak sites, respectively, in the clayey sand with 0.02–0.32% of carbonate content. Therefore, the values measured in the present study roughly fall within the same magnitude as those for clayey soils. In agreement with, this study Asmare (2014) also noted that the binding energy of P on the adsorption sites of clayey acidic soils of Farta district in northwestern highlands of Ethiopia was ranged from 0.21 to 0.96 L mg⁻¹.

It is evident from the data that the energy of adsorption (K_L) value was found to be greater for soils that had higher contents of oxyhydroxides of Fe and Al, higher sorption capacity (PSC), higher exchangeable Al (exAl) and lower oxalate extractable Phosphorous (P_ox) (Tables 3).

The maximum buffering capacity (MBC) of the soil, which is the product of Q_max and K_L, is a capacity factor that measures the ability of the soil to replenish phosphate ions to the soil solution (Asmare 2014). The MBC is potentially useful as a tool to characterize soil types especially for low concentration range because it describes both the nature and the capacity of P adsorption. According to the data presented in Table 3, the values of the MBC of the soils were ranged from 86.82 to 627.35 L kg⁻¹. It can be seen that soils with higher adsorption capacity, Fe_ox and Al_ox concentration, clay percent and exchangeable Al were appeared to have higher maximum buffering capacity. The soils with the highest MBC (SC1 and SC3) have higher adsorption capacity, reflecting low P supply into soil solution for a longer period as compared to the less buffered soils which can supply ample P to soil solution. On the other hand, soils with low buffering capacity will have more P in soil solution and will enhance P mobility in such soils.

The Freundlich adsorption capacity (K_f), which is a measure of the reactive surface area (relative adsorption capacity) of the soil, is presented in Table 3. It has been shown that the K_f values ranged from 123.32 (SD5) to 315.31 (SC1) mg kg⁻¹ respectively. It may be seen that the K_f value was higher for the high P adsorbing soils that adsorb more P per kg soil than the low P adsorbing soils indicating strong affinity of adsorbate (P) towards the adsorbent surfaces (soil). The variation observed in P sorption capacities (K_f) among soils from the assorted sites might be ascribed to differences in oxides of Al and Fe and clay content in soils (Obura 2008). Moreover, the K_f values of the current study were in the range found by Birru et al. (2003) who reported 90–4915 mg P kg⁻¹ for acidic soils of north western highland of Ethiopia.

Phosphorous buffer capacity (PBC) of soils plays an important role in both agronomic and environmental aspects of P management (Ehlert et al. 2003). Sorption isotherms are much used to characterize the retention of P and the PBC_f of soil (Yli-halla et al. 2002). Accordingly, the phosphorous buffer capacity was obtained for soils of each district from the slope of the linear equation by plotting P adsorbed against P equilibrium concentration at 0.2 mg L⁻¹. The result of this study indicated that PBC_f values determined at the standard P concentration of 0.2 mg P L⁻¹ increased with increase in the K_f values.

Model validation and interpretation

The P adsorption data fitted to the linearized Langmuir and Freundlich models are shown in Table 3. The coefficients of determination (R²) for the Freundlich model (0.99–1.00) were almost slightly greater than the Langmuir model (0.98–0.99) in the studied soils. Furthermore, the average distance at which the observed values deviated from the regression line (RMSE) of the Freundlich model (5.4–9.8) was smaller than that of the Langmuir model (19.8–28.0) (Table 3). Hence, the Freundlich model can be considered as a superior model for the description of the P adsorption characteristics of the soils in this particular study because of its lower (RMSE) and slightly higher R² values. Moreover, the Freundlich model, although originally empirical, implies that the affinity for adsorption decreases exponentially with increasing saturation of the surface which is closer to reality than the assumption of constant bonding energy inherent in the Langmuir equation. Therefore, phosphorous sorption by the studied soil was well described by the Freundlich equation.

The Freundlich constants K_f and N, which represent the intercept and slope of the log-transformed sorption isotherm, may be taken as a measure of the extent of adsorption and the energy of adsorption, for the thought-out soils respectively. The former could also be considered as capacity factor implying that a soil having larger K_f value has superior adsorbing capacity than otherwise. The Freundlich coefficient K_f ranged from 123.32 to 315.31 mg P kg⁻¹ (Table 3). In this study, SC1 exhibited the highest K_f (315.31 mg P kg⁻¹) value where as SD5 did show the lowest K_f (123.32 mg P kg⁻¹). The order of soils according to their adsorption capacities is found to be: SC1 > SC3 > SC4 > SC5 > SC6 > SC2 > SC7 > SD2 > SD4 > SD1 > SD3 > SD5. The observed difference in K_f value of the soils in the study area might be due to the disparity in the distribution of oxyhydroxides of Fe and Al. It has been noted that adsorption of P in soils is controlled to a large extent by the presence of amorphous Fe and Al (Agbenin 2003; Yan et al. 2013). These values are relatively high and comparable with those found by Asmare (2014) for the acidic soils of Farta district, northwestern highlands of Ethiopia which varied from 80 to 259 mg P kg⁻¹. On the other hand the soils were found to have lower K_f value compared to the one reported and by Zinabu et al. (2015) in acidic soils from Bule district, southern Ethiopia, which varied from 479 to 487 mg P kg⁻¹. The exponent term (N) in the Freundlich relationship describing solid phase P and solution P at equilibrium is less than one for all of the soils (Table 3). This indicates that the relationship is not curvilinear and suggests that adsorption of P is controlling solution P concentrations in most of the soils (Bertrand et al. 2003).

Phosphorus buffer capacity was obtained for each soil from the slope of the linear equation by plotting P adsorbed against P concentration at equilibrium for the adsorption dominated part of the isotherm (0.5–32 mg P L⁻¹). Phosphorous buffer capacity (PBC_f) of the soils varied from 140.06 to 342.82 L kg⁻¹ (Table 3). In the current study, all the studied soils appeared to have a very high PBC_f (Moody and Bolland 1999), the soils from Cheha being higher. It can be inferred that more added fertilizer P could be adsorbed, as I or Q is increased (Jensen and Jakobsen 1970) in soil samples from Cheha district compared to soils from Dinsho district. Moreover, the soils with the highest PBC (SC1) have higher adsorption capacity and would maintain low P supply in soil solution for a longer period as compared to least (SD5) buffered soils which can supply ample P to soil solution. On the other hand, soils with low buffering capacity will have more P in soil solution and will enhance P mobility in such soils. About 75% of the studied soils were within the range found by Asmare (2014) for eight acidic soils of northwestern highlands of Ethiopia.

Standard phosphorus fertilizer requirements (SPR)

The SPR_f of the soils calculated from the Freundlich equation (Table 3) at 0.2 mg P L⁻¹ is an estimate of P sorption potential (Jackman et al. 1997; Wang et al. 2000). The amount of P adsorbed at an equilibrium concentration of 0.2 mg P L⁻¹ was between 50.50 and 154.02 mg P kg⁻¹ of soil. Fox (1981) and Afif et al. (1993) indicated that this concentration (0.2 mg P L⁻¹) is an adequate external P requirement for most crops. The value of SPR_f ranged from 94.04 to 154.02 mg P kg⁻¹ for the soils of Cheha district. Similarly, the SPR_f of soils in Dinsho district varied from 50.50 to 95.33 mg kg⁻¹. The distinction in adsorption capacities of these soils might be ascribed to the difference in abundance and distribution of strongly reactive P adsorption sites on amorphous Fe and Al oxides (Chunye et al. 2009). In this regard different studies realized that Fe_ox and Al_ox were considered to be the key factors in regulating P adsorption due to its large surface area, variable-charge surface and high reactivity, especially in redox-changing environments (Makris et al. 2005; Wang et al. 2009; Yan et al. 2016). The higher values of SRP_f in case of Cheha soils indicate the need for application of more P fertilizers to maintain optimum crop production compared to soils collected from Dinsho district.

According to Sanchez and Uehara (1980), soils (SC2, SC3, SC4, SC5, SC6, SC7, SD1, SD2, SD3, SD4 and SD5) that adsorb less than 150 mg P kg⁻¹ soil to meet the SPR_f value of 0.2 mg L⁻¹ in soil solution were considered to be low adsorbing soil and the other adsorbing an amount exceeding this value was high P adsorbing ones (SC1). Furthermore, the results of the current study on the subject of SPR of these soils presented a comparable result with those found by Asmare (2014); Zinabu (2015) and Duffera and Robarge (1999) in different highly weathered acidic soils of Ethiopia (42–175 mg P kg⁻¹) in West Africa (Abekoe and Sahrawat 2001). As a case in point Duffera and Robarge (1999) reported that the amount of added P required maintaining a concentration of 0.2 mg P L⁻¹ in solution (SPR) ranged from 50 to 201 mg P kg⁻¹ for surface soil samples from non-cultivated and non-fertilized areas in Ethiopia. Likewise, Zinabu et al. (2015) has found that the SPR values of acidic soils of Bule and Wonago districts in southern Ethiopia ranging from 71.8 to 211 mg kg⁻¹.

The consumption of fertilizers in sub Saharan Africa was estimated to be 8 kg P ha⁻¹ (Morris et al. 2007) and the blanket recommendation for cereal crops in Ethiopia was 20 kg P ha⁻¹. However, in the present study at the 24 h of equilibration time, the SPR_f of the soils ranged from 50.50 to 154.02 mg P kg⁻¹ which was equivalent to the application of 115.64 to 352.71 kg P ha⁻¹ and superior than the blanket recommendation in Ethiopia by about a factor of 6–18.The differences in the SPR_f of the soils in the study sites indicate that application of blanket P fertilizer rates for all study sites is not feasible. The blanket recommendation of P fertilizer for Ethiopian soils is therefore, inadequate for optimal crop production at all the sites. This is because it can supply at most only 20 kg P ha⁻¹, which is much below the soils SPR_f of 115.64–352.71 kg P ha⁻¹. Soils of the study area were found to have analogous SPR_f values with soils appraised by Asmare (2014), where the application of P fertilizers based on the blanket recommendation in the northwestern highlands of Ethiopia could result in a substantial yield deficit. Therefore, a mechanism has to be devised to increase availability of P by attenuating the P high adsorption capacity of the soils in order to increase productivity especially for soils with relatively high P fixing capacity (Cheha district).

The SPR_f (0.2 mg L⁻¹) levels for the studied soils that were obtained after 24 h equilibration periods were not remain similar and the soil solution P (intensity factor) depends on the adsorbed P (capacity factor) or the buffering capacity of the soils (Fox 1981). Consequently, the use of soil test P fertilizer recommendation based on the adsorption curves together with plant response for the applied P for different crop varieties should be done for the soils of the study area rather than using the usual conventional practice which could underestimate or overestimate the amount P fertilizer to be applied. Since the SPR_f of the soils calculated from the Freundlich equation (Table 3) is an estimate of P sorption potential (Wang et al. 2000) and an adequate external P requirement for most crops (Afif et al. 1993), diverse crop varieties in the study area could require different amount of P fertilizer. Thus it could be inferred that the external and internal P requirement of a crop as well as variety has to be investigated to find a reasonable amount of fertilizer to be applied to a particular soil with respect to crops and sites.

Correlation between Freundlich adsorption indices and soil properties

The correlation analysis was done between the Freundlich adsorption indices (K_f, PBC_f, and SPR_f) and the various soil properties (Clay, exAl, CEC, OC, P_ox, Al_ox, Fe_ox, Mhlich 3 P, NH₄Cl-P, NaOH-Pi and HCl-P) and presented in Table 4. Adsorption parameters were strongly and positively correlated with soil properties i.e., [r = 0.89, P ≤ 0.01(K_f and Fe_ox); r = 0.87, P ≤ 0.01 (K_f and Al_ox); r = 0.89, P ≤ 0.01 (Al_ox and SPR_f); r = 0.84, P ≤ 0.01 (K_f and Clay); r = 0.62, P ≤ 0.05 (NaOH-pi and K_f); r = 0.81, P ≤ 0.01 (exAl and SPR_f); r = 0.91, P ≤ 0.01 (Fe_ox and SPR_f); r = 0.89, P ≤ 0.01(Al_ox and SPR_f)]. The adsorption parameters were positively and strongly correlated with Fe_ox and Al_ox indicating the presence of reactive and strong P adsorption sites on Fe and Al oxides (Chunye et al. 2009). The presence of high correlation between the adsorption parameters and the oxalate extractable Al and Fe suggest that those adsorption coefficients did play a prominent role in explaining P adsorption characteristics of the soils in terms of oxides of Fe and Al in the study area. It can also be seen from the correlation study that in soils where there was higher clay content, exAl, Al_ox and Fe_ox, concurrently higher SPR_f, PBC and K_f values were observed. It verified the expectation that higher phosphorous buffering capacity, fertilizer requirements and adsorption capacity is expected in soils where clay content, exAl and oxides of Fe and Al are dominating. This confirmed the significant influence of soil texture on P sorption capacity as reported by several authors (Yuan and Lucas 1982; Mozaffari and Sims 1994).

Table 4 Correlation table for Freundlich model coefficients and soil properties

A significant and negative correlation was found between the soil properties (CEC, OC, P_ox, NH₄Cl-P, and HCl-P) and the Freundlich adsorption parameters. However, NaOH-Pi was strongly and positively (p ≤ 0.01) correlated with adsorption coefficients. The compelling reason for strong positive association between NaOH-Pi and the adsorption parameters could be the greater contents of oxyhydroxides of Fe and Al which in turn vigorously stabilize NaOH-Pi in the soil (Yan et al. 2017). The significant and negative correlation between the organic carbon content and adsorption indices (K_f, SPR_f and PBC_f) (r = − 0.86, P ≤ 0.01; r = − 0.89, P ≤ 0.01, r = − 0.85, P ≤ 0.01) respectively, for soils was concurrent with several reports (Juo and Fox 1977 and Daly et al. 2001). However, there are results indicating positive correlation as well (Wild 1950; Börling et al. 2001). Moreover, as case in point other research results showed that OC can have a significant and positive relationship (Ayaz et al. 2010) and significant negative relationship (Burt et al. 2002; Moazed et al. 2010) with the adsorption capacity of the soils. From this strong association between these parameters and soil properties it could be inferred that in soils where we found high CEC, OC, P_ox, NH₄Cl-P and HCl-P there would be low adsorption capacity, phosphorus buffering capacity and phosphorous fertilizer requirements. Thus, the coefficients k_f (amount adsorbed), PBC_f (Phosphorous buffering capacity), SPR_f (standard phosphorous requirement) and N (buffer power) of Freundlich adsorption model were best predicted from CEC, Mehlich-3 P HCl-P, NH₄Cl-P, clay, Fe_ox, Al_ox, NaOH-pi and exAl and P_ox and therefore put forth a profound influence on the rate of P adsorbed onto the soils.

Conclusions

The adsorption study was conducted to found the relationship between adsorbed P and solution P to appraise the P adsorption properties of the soils by making use of appropriate empirical model and evaluate the correlation between adsorption indices and soil properties. The Freundlich model could be considered as the best model for the description of the P adsorption characteristics of the soils in this particular study area. The Freundlich coefficient K_f (adsorption capacity) value ranged from 123.32 to 315.31 mg P kg⁻¹ and depended on amorphous form of Fe and Al (i.e. Fe_ox and Al_ox). Consequently, the standard P requirements of the soils varied from 50.50 to 154.02 mg P kg⁻¹ of soil, implying the blanket recommendation of P fertilizer for Ethiopian soils is therefore, inadequate for optimal crop production in the study area and was much below the soils’ actual P requirements. Phosphorous buffer capacity (PBC_f) of the soils varied from 140.06 (SD5) to 342.82 L kg⁻¹ (SC1) and all of the premeditated acidic soils (100%) was classified under very high (> 90) phosphorous buffering capacity soils and would maintain low P supply in soil solution for a longer period. Strong and positive significant relationship was observed between the Freundlich adsorption parameters (K_f, PBC_f and SPR_f) and oxalate extractable Al and Fe (P ≤ 0.01). The Freundlich adsorption coefficients play a prominent role in explaining P adsorption characteristics of the soils in terms of oxides of Fe and Al in the study area. The amount of P adsorbed, Phosphorous buffering capacity, standard phosphorous requirement of the soils were best predicted from CEC, Mehlich-3 P HCl-P, NH₄Cl-P, clay, Fe_ox, Al_ox, NaOH-pi and exAl and P_ox and therefore put forth a considerate influence on the rate of P adsorbed onto the soils. Therefore, a mechanism has to be devised to increase availability of P by attenuating the P adsorption capacity of the soils in order to increase productivity especially for soils with relatively high P fixing capacity. The blanket P fertilizer rate recommendations in Ethiopia without the knowledge of external P requirement of each crop might have decreased yield in the study areas as it could have resulted in under-application of fertilizer P. Thus it could be inferred that the external and internal P requirement of a crop as well as variety has to be investigated to find a reasonable amount of fertilizer to be applied to a particular soil with respect to crops and sites.