Skip to main content

Table 3 Statistical evaluation of the mean annual and kiremit season rainfall of Zarima subbasin (the statistical evaluation of kiremit season mean rainfall is written in brackets

From: Evaluation of CORDEX Africa regional climate models performance in simulating climatology of Zarima sub-basin northwestern Ethiopia

Stations

Stastical metrics

Observed

HadReg4-7

HadCCLM

HadREMOO

MPI-Reg4-7

MPI-CCLM

MPI-REMOO

NorESM-Reg4-7

NorESM-CCLM

NorESM-REMOO

CanESM-RCM

Reg ensemble

CCLM ensemble

REMOO ensemble

Ensemble

Adiramets

BIAS

 

0.53 (0.22)

− 0.51 (− 0.94)

− 1.28 (− 1.49)

− 0.45 (− 0.71)

− 1.38 (− 2.00)

− 1.86 (− 2.04)

− 1.5 (− 1.93)

− 1.08 (− 1.46)

− 2.01 (− 2.12)

− 1.90 (− 2.11)

− 0.47 (− 0.81)

− 1.15 (− 1.48)

− 1.25 (− 1.65)

− 1.14 (− 1.46)

 

RMSE

 

247.54 (238.61)

263.54 (245.12)

291.39 (292.22)

332.77 (322.75)

261.17 (309.86)

386.65 (398.50)

368.39 (376.85)

310.37 (309.20)

426.25 (432.90)

322.58 (350.77)

180.88 (194.71)

197.14 (215.08)

208.82 (226.11)

180.16 (215.77)

 

r

 

0.76 (0.77)

0.68 (0.75)

0.72 (0.73)

0.61 (0.65)

0.82 (0.78)

0.73 (0.70)

0.76 (0.74)

0.64 (0.67)

0.71 (0.72)

0.78 (0.73)

0.87 (0.86)

0.88 (0.87)

0.87 (0.87)

0.89 (0.88)

 

CV

16.74 (17.84)

17.22 (18.09)

14.93 (15.83)

18.82 (20.42)

19.85 (21.62)

20.36 (22.67)

26.94 (28.21)

27.24 (28.39)

18.12 (19.39)

29.03 (31.87)

22.61 (24.74)

17.47 (18.79)

15.67 (16.99)

16.10 (17.50)

9.14 (9.14)

 

KGE

 

0.76 (0.77)

0.66 (0.72)

0.69 (0.69)

0.57 (0.59)

0.71 (0.64)

0.33 (0.34)

0.33 (0.35)

0.63 (0.66)

0.21 (0.16)

0.57 (0.52)

0.86 (0.85)

0.85 (0.85)

0.85 (0.85)

0.87 (0.85)

Debarik

BIAS

 

0.38 (− 0.15)

0.45 (− 0.47)

− 0.12 (0.08)

0.07 (0.03)

1.22 (0.60)

− 0.54 (-0.99)

− 0.10 (-0.21)

0.4 (− 0.21)

− 0.48 (− 0.61)

− 0.08 (− 0.23)

0.12 (− 0.11)

0.69 (− 0.33)

− 0.38 (− 0.51)

0.12 (− 0.22)

 

RMSE

 

167.39 (143.57)

139.47 (101.92)

145.73 (142.63)

146.93 (129.49)

136.59 (103.52)

189.87 (168.26)

160.95 (136.74)

186.88 (167.61)

206.89 (205.75)

129.11 (127.55)

127.76 (103.34)

103.59 (83.73)

142.11 (139.50)

84.11 (77.43)

 

r

 

0.90 (0.60)

0.91 (0.77)

0.87 (0.64)

0.90 (0.56)

0.95 (0.78)

0.86 (0.51)

0.88 (0.60)

0.89 (0.44)

0.85 (0.48)

0.93 (0.72)

0.92 ( 0.73)

0.94 (0.84)

0.91 (0.63)

0.96 (0.87)

 

CV

12.02 (12.23)

11.93 (13.63)

10.24 (10.99)

13.58 (14.33)

9.10 (9.56)

11.95 (10.89)

13.07 (14.10)

12.80 (12.49)

14.21 (13.44)

17.19 (18.73)

13.49 (14.68)

9.27 (9.57)

9.35 (9.11)

12.17 (13.48)

8.56 (13.44)

 

KGE

 

0.89 (13.58)

0.83 (0.75)

0.81 (0.60)

0.74 (0.51)

0.92 (0.71)

0.83 (0.48)

0.86 (0.60)

0.79 (0.44)

0.54 (0.26)

0.86 (0.66)

0.76 (0.66)

0.77 (0.70)

0.91 (0.61)

0.71 (0.72)

Ketema

BIAS

 

0.02 (0.02)

0.18 (1.57)

0.17 (− 2.02)

0.20 (1.01)

0.20 (1.56)

0.11 (− 2.24)

-0.02 (− 2.53)

0.17 (0.92)

0.04 (− 0.27)

0.09 (− 0.62)

0.07 (− 0.50)

0.18 (1.35)

0.11 (− 1.60)

0.12 (− 0.26)

niguse

RMSE

 

156.75 (135.76)

202.90 (180.83)

224.79 (201.65)

180.50 (159.84)

238.43 (149.41)

281.55 (256.70)

282.94 (259.73)

199.98 (145.27)

145.69 (132.76)

113.84 (119.35)

138.47 (118.40)

176.39 (114.90)

175.21 (152.87)

98.15 (94.13)

 

r

 

0.69 (0.71)

0.73 (0.62)

0.60(0.60)

0.68 (0.66)

0.73 (0.76)

0.41 (0.45)

0.48 (0.46)

0.72 (0.74)

0.72 (0.73)

0.84 (0.78)

0.75 (0.77)

0.84 (0.86)

0.71 (0.73)

0.88 (0.86)

 

CV

16.11 (16.34)

16.13 (16.18)

16.19 (16.18)

21.20 (20.56)

16.01 (15.99)

18.36 (15.87)

22.77 (24.73)

23.69 (24.78)

18.50 (17.18)

14.39 (16.18)

15.33 (15.01)

14.89 (14.43)

15.39 (13.49)

16.12 (16.34)

13.51 (13.44)

 

KGE

 

0.69 (0.71)

0.71 (0.61)

0.48 (0.52)

0.68 (0.65)

0.67 (0.75)

0.27 (0.24)

0.29 (0.25)

0.68 (0.73)

0.72 (0.72)

0.83 (0.76)

0.74 (0.74)

0.80 (0.77)

0.70 (0.72)

0.80 (0.77)

Maytsebri

BIAS

 

0.04 (0.04)

2.28 (2.29)

− 1.73 (2.47)

1.34 (2.91)

2.81 (2.99)

− 2.30(1.29)

-2.63 (− 0.79)

1.78 (2.25)

− 0.56 (0.21)

− 0.44 (0.83)

− 0.42 (0.72)

2.29 (2.51)

− 1.64 (1.32)

0.06 (1.46)

 

RMSE

 

246.86 (213.73)

290.77 (243.59)

328.52 (303.37)

271.66 (231.16)

260.65 (248.68)

320.84 (280.46)

153.11 (160.84)

229.88 (191.54)

202.34 (181.56)

184.67 (166.26)

176.86 (158.97)

218.55 (185.55)

251.72 (220.37)

181.65 (154.47)

 

r

 

0.73 (0.70)

0.64 (0.62)

0.71 (0.63)

0.70 (0.71)

0.75 (0.72)

0.70 (0.65)

0.70 (0.63)

0.68 (0.65)

0.71 (0.63)

0.72 (0.67)

0.76 (0.730

0.84 (0.81)

0.76 (0.69)

0.83 (0.80)

 

CV

14.82 (14.12)

32.66 (29.87)

23.86 (22.62)

30.27 (30.30)

19.63 (18.69)

19.89 (21.33)

34.12 (32.90)

21.88 (21.10)

16.07 (14.39)

26.49 (24.46)

21.08 (21.02)

23.02 (22.54)

16.27 (16.69)

28.32 (26.94)

20.72 (20.22)

 

KGE

 

− 0.23 (− 0.16)

0.27 (0.27)

− 0.1 (− 0.21)

0.52 (0.53)

0.53 (0.39)

− 0.34 (− 0.38)

0.44 (0.38)

0.63 (0.63)

0.16 (0.18)

0.49 (0.41)

0.39 (0.34)

0.74 (0.70)

0.05 (0.04)

0.55 (0.51)

Zarima

BIAS

 

− 0.08 (− 0.45)

− 0.96 (1.75)

− 16.27 (− 0.41)

− 6.97 (− 0.62)

0.16 (− 0.51)

− 16.01 (0.13)

"− 14.87 (0.95)

− 3.08 (-1.54)

− 17.93 (0.44)

1.30 (1.08)

0.25 (− 0.04)

− 0.92 (− 1.27)

0.25 (0.05)

0.00 (− 0.27)

 

RMSE

 

0.68 (258.79)

− 0.27 (248.25)

-0.15 (254.44)

− 0.23 (280.36)

0.00 (252.91)

− 0.03 (312.57)

− 0.09 (313.16)

− 0.18 (263.13)

− 0.06 (249.70)

0.80 (320.82)

0.86 (177.00)

0.93 (172.33)

0.84 (184.37)

0.95 (102.05)

 

r

 

0.68 (0.72)

0.69 (0.73)

0.69 (0.71)

0.79 (0.78)

0.74 (0.75)

0.76 (0.76)

0.72 (0.72)

0.77 (0.78)

0.67 (0.67)

0.80 (0.76)

0.86 (0.87)

0.93 (0.95)

0.84 (0.85)

0.95 (0.96)

 

CV

16.74 (17.84)

18.79 (17.75)

14.74 (16.24)

55.16 (16.82)

16.37 (23.55)

14.93 (18.73)

21.36 (25.04

48.91 (21.29)

14.75 (18.43)

89.76 (18.73)

22.17 (23.13)

17.80 (17.82)

13.87 (14.17)

17.03 (17.03)

15.26 (15.35)

 

KGE

 

0.66 (0.72)

0.66 (0.71)

− 1.43 (0.71)

0.62 (0.61)

0.72 (0.74)

0.18 (0.53)

− 1.06 (0.65)

0.71 (0.77)

− 3.45 (0.66)

0.61 (0.61)

0.84 (0.87)

0.81 (0.78)

0.84 (0.84)

0.90 (0.86)