Skip to main content

Table 5 Grain yield of common bean investigated from three genotypes (Dursitu, Kufanzik and Gofta) over four experimental locations (Babile, Fedis, Haramaya and Hirna), in eastern Ethiopian, in 2012/2013 cropping season

From: Effect of genotypes-Rhizobium-environment interaction on nodulation and productivity of common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) in eastern Ethiopia

Inoculation Grain yield (kg ha−1)
Dursitu Kufanzik Gofta
Haramaya Hirna Babile Fedis Haramaya Hirna Babile Fedis Haramaya Hirna Babile Fedis
NSCBR-14 2323.1a 2554.35a 1340.6ab 1093.3b 3800.1a 2829.3ab 1098.6d 1607.0abc 3735.6a 3470.6ab 954.0e 2384.4ab
NSCBR-(25)2 2192.9ab 2107.69bcd 653.7c 1285.6ab 3206.5bc 2634.3ab 1987.1a 1801.3ab 3339.8abc 3201.4abc 1657.8abc 2570.0a
NSCBR-59 2059.8abc 2486.94a 796.5c 1616.8a 3105.8bc 2565.6ab 1619.8abc 1716.7abc 3608.7ab 3625.7a 1913.1a 1956.3abc
NSCBR-31 2239.1ab 2132.96bc 1101.2abc 1328.1ab 2915.8bc 2910.8a 1046.6d 1938.8a 3062.1bc 3092.9bc 1631.9abc 2497.4ab
NSCBR-16 2454.9a 2122.41bcd 786.9c 1285.2ab 2983.8bc 2657.0ab 1932.4ab 1693.1abc 3265.8ab 3334.4ab 1080.1de 1776.4bc
NSCBR-18 1683.9c 1803.06de 1054.2bc 1162.4ab 3007.3bc 2817.5ab 1411.9 cd 1615.7abc 3215.7a 3648.0a 1232.8cde 2659.6a
NSCBR-57 2441.9a 1615.56e 892.7bc 1396.7ab 2761.6c 2433.8b 1442.5bcd 1333.8bc 3688.4bc 3096.4bc 1390.0b-e 1577.2c
NSCBR-25 2139.1ab 1918.89 cde 1043.5bc 1097.6b 3195.3bc 2611.5ab 1474.8bcd 1248.6c 3241.9c 2759.7c 1774.9ab 2024.3abc
−VE Control 1873.0bc 1750.93e 790.6c 1063.8b 2727.0c 2534.2ab 1221.9cd 1432.4abc 2932.3c 2739.8c 1490.0a-d 2065.6abc
+VE Control 2263.1ab 2292.59ab 1543.0a 1238.9ab 3375.9ab 2776.4ab 1501.0a-d 1652.2abc 3498.4a 3609.4a 1868.1ab 2537.0a
Mean 2167.07 2078.54 1000.28 1256.83 3107.92 2677.03 1473.66 1603.96 3358.89 3257.82 1499.25 2204.82
LSD 408.32 325.07 473.22 517.43 537.01 452.72 500.47 529.87 582.44 502.05 484.42 734.04
CV (%) 6.51 5.40 16.36 14.24 5.98 5.85 11.75 11.43 6.00 5.33 11.18 11.51
P value *** *** *** * *** * *** ** *** *** *** ***
F value 8.86 22.88 8.56 2.65 8.66 2.80 9.87 4.00 5.30 11.44 11.66 6.51
  1. Means within the same column followed by the same letter are not significantly different at the 5% probability level by Tukey’s test
  2. −VE-negative control (no inoculation and N application), +VE control −20 kg N ha−1; NSCBR National soil Common Bean Rhizobium
  3. * Significant at 0.05
  4. ** Significant at 0.01
  5. *** Significant at 0.001